Duped by Davros

Doctor Who wallpaper.
Most of the time, when I’m watching a movie or TV show, I can see right through the plot twists. I catch the foreshadowing and can predict what’s coming (and sometimes dialogue—which means that it must be pretty poorly written). I like to think that I can see a lie coming from a mile away because I have worked in pastoral ministry for almost 20 years.

But the episode of Doctor Who, “The Witch’s Familiar,” had my poor brain in a tizzy. I should have seen through Davros’ act—he even gave himself away early in the conversation when he called the Daleks’ compassion a “defect.” He told the Doctor that compassion “grows strong and fierce in you like a cancer” and that it “will kill you in the end,” to which the Doctor replied, “I wouldn’t die of anything else.”

I mean, he completely laid his evilness out there. He said it flat out. Could he have been more obvious?!

But, I got sucked in to his tears. I got sucked into his apparent remorse right along with the Doctor.

He’s Davros—he’s pure evil! But, I’m Catholic! No one is pure evil—everyone can be redeemed!

Initially, using a tactic that would have worked on himself at one time, Davros tried to tempt the Doctor to touch the cables that would suck his regenerative power out of him by making him think that he could wipe out all of the Daleks. The Doctor didn’t succumb. So, when that didn’t work, like the super-evil villain that he is, Davros changed gears and went for what he sees as the Doctor’s greatest weakness (and just went on and on about it!)—his compassion. Davros cried. He asked to look into his face like a dying family member would request. He asked if he was a good man. He flattered him. He even made a joke, for crying out loud!!

And all the while, I found myself in the midst of an interior struggle—he’s Davros—he’s pure evil! But, I’m Catholic! No one is pure evil—everyone can be redeemed! But, there will be more shows—if Davros turns good what will become of the best monsters of the Doctor Who canon? He’s so twisted and corrupted—he can’t be good! But, everyone can be good! Seriously—being Catholic makes being a sci-fi fan exhausted.

Of course, Davros is just as evil as he claimed to be earlier on. It was all a trick to save himself and the other Daleks. But, as with most supervillains, Davros’ selfishness grew into hubris, which always brings destruction.

Compassion made the Doctor (and me) gullible… Davros’ lies made us vulnerable. But, vulnerability does not necessarily mean weak or ineffective. Compassion might have duped the Doctor for a little while, but it is essentially what makes him strong. And in the end, when Missy tried to trick the Doctor into killing “the Dalek who killed Clara” (which was Clara in a Dalek can)—it was mercy and compassion that made him level-headed and stayed his hand, ultimately saving Clara.

So, is compassion worth the roller coaster? Is it worth getting duped and made vulnerable? Is it worth dying for? The Doctor thinks so. Jesus thought so. And so do I.

The original version of this article appeared in The Rogue.

Jennifer Schlameuss-Perry

Jennifer Schlameuss-Perry

Contributing Writer at Area of Effect
Jen is a pastoral minister, wife, mother, ninja and writer. She loves sci-fi, superheroes, and classic literature, and prefers to share her Catholic faith through such lenses. Her book, "Comic Con Christianity" is available from Paulist Press.
Jennifer Schlameuss-Perry

Latest posts by Jennifer Schlameuss-Perry (see all)